How to Run a Successful Logo Contest
CrySP recently ran a logo design contest on 99designs. This page will contain the postmortem, but is currently a work-in-progress until the winning design is finalized.
- There is a difference between Gold and Platinum
- Be aware of designer demographics and timezones
- Rounds end at the same time of day the contest starts
- Be aware of when the weekend is
- You have multiple days between rounds
- Administrators follow a script that will make the contest blind upon request
- Understand: blind contests protect designers, private contests protect customers
- Make your contest blind
- Assemble a design committee to guide the contest
- Make a rigorous feedback loop
- Define the meaning of ratings in advance
- Rate and comment on every submission
- Decline submissions that are obsolete to keep the listing clean
- You can see the entries for other contests with URL editing
- Withdrawn submissions are obscured but still save-able (but note you don't own the copyright)
- Be aware of how little pay the designers get
- Contests can be extended upon request
- Make a comprehensive design brief
- Inspirational logos in the design brief will be taken literally
- Read the 99designs blog posts on types of logos and common logos (you should be familiar with the V-Man and know the difference between a pictorial mark and a wordmark)
- Post regular announcements (these also go out to watchers)
- Invite designers to your contest personally, but note the economics surrounding top-level designers
- Change your account avatar so that designers don't draw design inspiration from the default (the first letter of your name)
- The finalization / handover phase is only meant for small revisions. You lose your leverage!