Speaker: Date: For questions, answer either yes or no. Please also provide some additional feedback, especially in the negative case. For items asking for a summary rating, please give a number from 1 to 5, where 1 is poor and 5 is excellent. Feedback questions: - Were the slides clear and engaging? - Was the presentation clear and easy to follow? - Was the presenter prepared and knowledgeable of the paper's contents? - Did the presenter respect the alloted presentation's time (20min)? - Was it clear what the audience should take away from the talk? - Did the talk stimulate interesting questions? - Did the speaker come up with interesting questions? - Was the speaker able to adequately steer the paper's discussion? - Please provide an overall rating for the talk (1 to 5): Optional: Other Comments (e.g., strengths, drawbacks, suggestions for improvement)