-------------------------------------------------------------- --- For your convenience, this form can be processed by EasyChair --- automatically. You can fill out this form offline and then --- upload it to EasyChair. Several review forms can be uploaded --- simultaneously. You can modify your reviews as many times as --- you want. --- When filling out the review form please mind --- the following rules: --- (1) Lines starting with --- are comments. EasyChair will --- ignore them. Do not start lines in your review with --- --- as they will be ignored. You can add comments to the --- review form or remove them --- (2) Lines starting with *** are used by EasyChair. Do not --- remove or modify these lines. -------------------------------------------------------------- *** SUBMISSION NUMBER: *** TITLE: *** AUTHORS: *** PC MEMBER ANONYMOUS ID: -------------------------------------------------------------- *** REVIEW: --- Please provide a detailed review, including justification for --- your scores. This review will be sent to the authors unless --- the PC chairs decide not to do so. This field is required. --- In addition list 2 or more reasons why the paper should be --- accepted AND 2 or more reasons why the paper should be rejected. -------------------------------------------------------------- *** REMARKS FOR THE PROGRAMME COMMITTEE: --- If you wish to add any remarks for PC members, please write --- them below. These remarks will only be used during the PC --- meeting. They will not be sent to the authors. This field is --- optional. -------------------------------------------------------------- --- In the evaluations below, UNCOMMENT the line with your --- evaluation or confidence. You can also remove the --- irrelevant lines *** OVERALL EVALUATION: --- 3 (strong accept) --- 2 (accept) --- 1 (weak accept) --- 0 (borderline paper) --- -1 (weak reject) --- -2 (reject) --- -3 (strong reject) *** REVIEWER'S CONFIDENCE: --- 4 (expert) --- 3 (high) --- 2 (medium) --- 1 (low) --- 0 (null) *** TECHNICAL QUALITY: from 1 (lowest) to 5 (highest) --- 5 (excellent) --- 4 (good) --- 3 (fair) --- 2 (poor) --- 1 (very poor) *** PRESENTATION: from 1 (lowest) to 5 (highest) --- 5 (excellent) --- 4 (good) --- 3 (fair) --- 2 (poor) --- 1 (very poor) *** ORIGINALITY: from 1 (lowest) to 5 (highest) --- 5 (excellent) --- 4 (good) --- 3 (fair) --- 2 (poor) --- 1 (very poor) *** FOR A COURSE PROJECT I WOULD RATE THIS PAPER: from 1 (lowest) to 5 (highest) --- 5 (excellent) --- 4 (good) --- 3 (fair) --- 2 (poor) --- 1 (very poor) *** END