==+== CS854-Fall-2021 Review Form
==-== DO NOT CHANGE LINES THAT START WITH "==+==" OR "==*==".
==-== For further guidance, or to upload this file when you are done, go to:
==-== https://uw-cs854-perf21.hotcrp.com/offline

==+== =====================================================================
==+== Begin Review
==+== Reviewer: Tim Brecht <brecht@cs.uwaterloo.ca>

==+== Paper Number

(Enter paper number here)

==+== Review Readiness
==-== Enter "Ready" if the review is ready for others to see:

Ready

==*== Overall merit
==-== Choices:
==-==    1. Reject
==-==    2. Weak reject
==-==    3. Weak accept
==-==    4. Accept
==-==    5. Strong accept
==-== Enter the number of your choice:

(Your choice here)

==*== Writing Quality
==-== Choices:
==-==    1. Unacceptable
==-==    2. Needs improvement
==-==    3. Adequate
==-==    4. Well-written
==-==    5. Outstanding
==-== Enter the number of your choice:

(Your choice here)

==*== Reviewer Expertise and/or Confidence
==-==    At some conferences these could be separate fields (Expertise and
==-==    Confidence). I've blended them here because typically students
==-==    don't have much expertise for many of the class projects
==-== Choices:
==-==    1. No familiarity (No confidence whatsoever)
==-==    2. Some familiarity (Somewhat confident)
==-==    3. Knowledgeable (Quite Confident)
==-==    4. Expert (Highly Confident)
==-== Enter the number of your choice:

(Your choice here)

==*== Paper summary
==-==    (1-2 sentences)
==-== Markdown styling and LaTeX math supported.



==*== Strengths
==-==    What are the paper’s important strengths? Just a couple of
==-==    sentences, please.
==-== Markdown styling and LaTeX math supported.



==*== Weaknesses
==-==    What are the paper’s important weaknesses? Just a couple
==-==    sentences, please.
==-== Markdown styling and LaTeX math supported.



==*== Given the Strengths and Weaknesses, Justify your Decision for Overall
==*==    Merit
==-==    Briefly justify why you think the paper should be accepted or
==-==    rejected.
==-== Markdown styling and LaTeX math supported.



==*== Comments to authors
==-==    Provide any additional information that would be useful to the
==-==    authors that you haven't already(e.g., things that could be
==-==    improved that you haven't already described).
==-== Markdown styling and LaTeX math supported.



==*== Overall Merit as a Course Project
==-== (hidden from authors)
==-==    For a course project I would rate this paper as
==-== Choices:
==-==    1. Unacceptable
==-==    2. Poor
==-==    3. Average
==-==    4. Good
==-==    5. Excellent
==-== Enter the number of your choice:

(Your choice here)

==*== Comments for PC (optional)
==-== (hidden from authors)
==-==    This field is communicating things to the PC that you might not
==-==    want to the authors to see.
==-== Markdown styling and LaTeX math supported.



==+== Scratchpad (for unsaved private notes)

==+== End Review