Paper Title:

1. Overall Rating
[ ] Strong Accept
[ ] Accept
[ ] Weak Accept
[ ] Weak Reject
[ ] Reject


2. Primary Focus
[ ] Theory
[ ] Algorithmic Improvement
[ ] Systems
[ ] Implementation
[ ] Empirical Evaluation


3. Novelty
[ ] High
[ ] Medium
[ ] Low


4. Technical Depth
[ ] High
[ ] Medium
[ ] Low


5. Presentation
[ ] Very good
[ ] Adequate
[ ] Not good


6. Reviewer Confidence
[ ] High
[ ] Medium
[ ] Low


7. Justification of Decision (one paragraph)




8. Detailed comments (please number each comment)